Masonry Repointing Methods: How Brick Joints Are Repaired


Repointing means cutting out deteriorated mortar from the joints of a masonry wall and replacing it with new mortar. Done well, it follows a fixed sequence: find the failed joints, remove the old mortar to a sound depth without touching the brick, pack in a softer, compatible mortar in thin layers, tool the joint to match the wall and keep it damp while it cures. Each step has a way to go wrong, and on a brick building in New York City, Long Island, Westchester or northern New Jersey, the mistakes are expensive. Below is how the methods work and where a licensed contractor earns the fee.
TL;DR
Repointing replaces failed mortar only. Firm, intact joints should generally be left alone, and only open, cracked or deeply eroded joints need work.
Remove old mortar to about twice the joint width (commonly 1/2 to 1 inch), using hand tools where the brick is old or soft, and never widen the joint or chip brick edges.
Use a mortar no stronger than the original. Too hard a mix traps moisture and spalls the brick face.
Pack in thin lifts, tool each at thumbprint hardness, and cure damp for at least 72 hours.
Wall height, access and exterior wall inspection rules make most repointing in this region a job for a licensed, insured contractor.
Table of Contents
What repointing is, and how it differs from tuckpointing
The National Park Service’s Preservation Brief 2 defines repointing as removing deteriorated mortar from masonry joints and replacing it with new mortar. It was written for historic buildings, but the guidance applies to other masonry buildings as well, which is why it is the reference point for most good practice.
You will hear the word tuckpointing used for the same job. The Brick Industry Association notes that the ASTM standard E 2260 treats tuckpointing as a synonym for repointing. The same word also names a decorative method in which the joint is filled flush with mortar matched to the brick color, and a narrow strip of contrasting mortar is laid on top. In everyday contractor talk in the New York area, if someone offers to tuckpoint your facade, they almost always mean repointing.
The practical difference for you is the finish you want. Repointing restores the wall’s original look and its weather protection. Decorative tuckpointing changes the look and is a separate choice.
Does your wall need it?
Not every worn joint needs replacing. The Virginia Department of Historic Resources advises that firm, intact mortar eroded less than 1/3 inch should generally be left alone, and that repointing be reserved for joints that are open, deeply eroded, cracked or separated. The Brick Industry Association’s Brick Brief makes the same point: repair defective joints only, because sound original mortar is better than unnecessary replacement.
Walk the wall and look for:
Mortar that is crumbling, sandy or missing, so you can slide a key or screwdriver tip into the joint.
Hairline or open cracks that follow the joints.
Gaps where the mortar has pulled away from the brick.
Water stains, efflorescence (white salt deposits) or damp interior plaster near a failing area.
Bricks whose faces are flaking, which can point to moisture trapped behind them. Our guide to spalling brick repair explains how to tell a small spot from recurring damage.
A full wall rarely needs complete repointing. A careful survey that marks only the failed joints keeps cost down and keeps more of the original wall intact.
Step 1: Choose the mortar before you touch the wall
Mortar choice decides whether the repair lasts 30 years or damages the wall in five. The rule is simple: the new mortar must be no stronger than the old one.
The Brick Industry Association’s Maintenance of Brick Masonry says to match the original mortar’s ingredients and proportions, and that its compressive strength must not exceed the original, to avoid brick damage and spalling. If the original is unknown, laboratory testing can identify its ingredients, proportions and strength. The General Services Administration adds that repointing mortar should be softer and more permeable than the masonry and original mortar, so it relieves stress and lets moisture pass out through the joint.
This is the most common failure on older buildings. A hard, Portland-cement-heavy mix looks fine on day one. Then water that would normally leave through the joint is forced through the brick, and the brick face starts to flake.
Where this goes wrong: a bag of general-purpose mortar mix from a home center is not matched to your wall. Matching color, sand and strength to an older pre-war brick building is a judgment call that benefits from experience, and a trial section on the wall is the way to confirm it before the full job.
Step 2: Remove the old mortar
This is where most damage happens. The aim is to take out the failed mortar and leave the brick edges and the joint width exactly as they were.
How deep to cut
The National Park Service recommends removing old mortar to at least 2 to 2.5 times the joint width, commonly about 1/2 to 1 inch for brick joints, and continuing deeper where the mortar is loose or disintegrated. The Brick Industry Association gives a similar rule: at least twice the joint width, generally 3/4 inch, or until sound mortar is reached. Shallow removal is the usual reason new mortar falls out within a few winters, because it has too little surface to grip.
Hand tools or power tools
Hand chisels and mash hammers are slower, but the National Park Service identifies them as generally the lowest risk to historic masonry and capable of the best result. Power tools are not banned, but they demand skill:
The Brick Industry Association warns that a grinder on head joints (the short vertical joints) may not reach full depth without cutting into adjacent brick, so what remains there must be taken out with a chisel.
The New York City Housing Authority’s 2024 brick repointing guideline prohibits power tools on vertical joints and allows electric grinders only on large horizontal joints. Where saw-cutting is used, it calls for a saw with an attached HEPA vacuum to capture dust.
On one National Park Service project at Fort Andrews, crews used chisels for crumbling mortar and an angle grinder only for tougher mortar, and only when it could be operated safely.
The pattern across all of these: grinders for long, wide horizontal joints in hard brick, chisels for everything else, and no tool that widens the joint or chips the arris (the crisp edge) of the brick.
Dust and debris
Cutting mortar produces fine dust and a surprising volume of rubble from a full elevation. It needs to be contained and cleared, and the debris needs a plan. If you are weighing options for brick debris removal and disposal, plan it before the work starts so loose mortar and brick fragments do not sit on a terrace, sidewalk or loading area.
Step 3: Clean and dampen the joints
Once the old mortar is out, the joint must be clean. The Brick Industry Association says to remove dust and debris by brushing, oil-free compressed air or water rinsing, and to remove thin slivers of old mortar from the brick so the new mortar bonds.
Then comes moisture control. The GSA specification for repointing historic masonry requires joints to be damp but with no standing water, and calls for wetting the wall below the work area to reduce staining. A dry joint pulls water out of fresh mortar too fast, and the mortar cures weak. A soaking joint dilutes the mortar and stains the wall.
This step is easy to get slightly wrong, which is the problem: the result may look fine for a season, then fail.
Step 4: Place the mortar in thin lifts
The mortar should be pressed into the joint by hand and compacted, not smeared on the surface. The GSA specification requires hand placement and, for joints deeper than 3/4 inch, compacted lifts, with each lift thumbprint-hard before the next goes in. The NYCHA guideline is stricter: fill in layers no thicker than 1/4 inch.

Thumbprint-hard means firm enough that pressing a thumb leaves a mark but does not push the mortar out. Reaching that point depends on temperature, humidity, sun and wind, so it varies by elevation and by day. A crew working a shaded north wall in November faces different timing than one on a sunny south wall in July.
Tools for placing mortar are typically a hawk (a flat board that holds mortar), a pointing trowel and a jointer. The National Park Service’s Fort Andrews account describes the same trowel-or-hawk-and-jointer approach.
Step 5: Tool the joint and match the profile
The finished profile is not only cosmetic. The National Park Service stresses matching the profile of sound original work rather than imposing a new one. The GSA specification says to tool joints to match an approved mock-up, which is a sample panel approved before full production.
Joint profile | What it looks like | Where it fits |
Concave | Rounded, pressed in with a jointer | Common on brickwork, sheds water well |
Flush | Mortar level with the brick face | Matches many older walls; needs careful tooling |
Raised or tuck-style | Narrow band standing proud of the joint | Decorative, historical match only |
Choose from what the sound sections of your wall already show. Mixing profiles on one elevation makes the repair visible from the street.
After tooling, excess mortar is removed with a stiff natural-bristle brush. The GSA specification says not to use a metal brush, which scratches the brick and can leave marks.
Step 6: Cure it damp
Fresh mortar gains strength through hydration, which needs water. Both the GSA specification and the NYCHA guideline call for keeping the mortar damp for at least 72 hours. In practice that means misting at intervals, shading from direct sun and protecting from hard rain. A repair left to dry in the sun can look finished and then crumble when the first freeze-thaw cycle hits.
Why repointing in this region is rarely a DIY job
Masonry work is generally not something an inexperienced homeowner should take on, as the Virginia Department of Historic Resources puts it. The method looks simple in a video, but the real work is judgment: how deep, what mix, which tool, when to tool the joint and how to cure it. On top of that, much of the work happens high above a sidewalk or yard.
For property managers and building owners in New York City the rules are firmer. The Department of Buildings’ facade compliance program requires inspections called critical examinations, performed only by a DOB-approved Qualified Exterior Wall Inspector. Conditions classed as unsafe must be repaired within 90 days, and if repairs are not finished in that time, a time extension request must be filed. Public protection such as a sidewalk shed must stay in place until the department approves an amended report. Failed mortar joints are among the conditions that turn into these repair items, so a repointing schedule that runs ahead of the inspection cycle keeps a building out of that position. The DOB page also explains which buildings are covered and how the filing works, so confirm your building’s status there.

What to ask of a masonry contractor
The Brick Industry Association’s Brick Brief says repointing is labor-intensive and recommends checking a craftsperson’s experience through prior work or a trial panel before hiring. A good bid will cover:
How many joints or what area will be repointed, and why those joints.
The mortar specification and how it matches the existing wall.
The removal method and dust control.
A sample panel on a discreet section.
Scaffold or swing-stage access, sidewalk protection and permits where required.
Insurance and a written warranty on labor and materials.
We are a general contractor, so we look at a failing joint as part of the whole wall. Open mortar joints let water into the building. That is why we treat repointing together with the exterior envelope: the brick, the joints, the flashing, the waterproofing and any damage that has already started inside. Our exterior envelope repair and waterproofing work, and our masonry restoration, are built for exactly this. We are licensed and insured, we work in line with local building codes, and we give warranties on labor and materials. For property managers and facility managers in New York City, we also handle DOB and DOT violation removal, so a facade repair and the paperwork around it can sit with one contractor. Our advice is the same for a single-family brownstone in Brooklyn and a commercial building in Westchester: repair the failed joints, match the mortar, and fix the cause of the water. DJ
Hiring DJ Custom Contracting for masonry and exterior repair
DJ Custom Contracting LLC is a residential and commercial general contractor, established in 2018, serving New York City, Long Island, Westchester County and northern New Jersey. Our Building and Facility Maintenance page covers exterior envelope repair and waterproofing and a comprehensive preventative maintenance program, and our Exterior Renovation page covers a full exterior makeover. Homeowners, business owners, property managers and facility managers can start from our services overview.

If you manage a building with a DOB or DOT violation, tell us at the start. We remove those violations as part of our work, and we can plan the masonry repair around it.
Planning the work: timing and related repairs
Repointing is best planned around the season and around the other exterior work on the building.
Temperature. Mortar needs to cure damp and unfrozen. The tri-state region’s freezing winters make spring through fall the working season, which is why spring is the busiest time for masonry crews.
Order of work. Roof edge, parapet and gutter repairs, and window and sealant work, come before repointing, so new joints are not damaged by later trades.
Related damage. If bricks are flaking on the face, repointing alone will not solve it. See the spalling guide above for when damaged units need replacement.
Adjacent surfaces. Patios, steps and walkways take the same freeze-thaw punishment. Our paver patio maintenance guide covers care for hardscape beside the wall.
For commercial and multi-family properties, scheduling repointing with other facade work also avoids paying twice for scaffold and sidewalk protection.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between repointing and tuckpointing?
In most trade usage they mean the same thing: removing failed mortar and replacing it. The Brick Industry Association notes that the ASTM standard uses tuckpointing as a synonym for repointing. The term also names a decorative method with a flush, brick-colored bed and a narrow contrasting strip, so confirm which finish a bid describes.
What is the best mortar mix for repointing brick?
The best mix is the one that matches the original in ingredients and proportions and is no stronger than it. Official guidance favors softer, more permeable mortar, such as lime-based mortar, on older masonry. If the original is unknown, laboratory analysis can identify it.
How deep should old mortar be removed?
At least twice the joint width, commonly 1/2 to 1 inch for brick, or deeper until sound mortar is reached. Cutting shallower than that leaves too little depth for the new mortar to hold.
Can I repoint brick myself?
Masonry work is generally not something an inexperienced homeowner should take on, according to the Virginia Department of Historic Resources. Mortar choice, joint removal and curing all affect the wall, and most work in our area is above ground level. A licensed, insured contractor like DJ Custom Contracting can survey the wall and carry out the repair.
Sources
Preservation Brief 2: Repointing Mortar Joints in Historic Masonry Buildings (National Park Service)
Brick Brief: Repointing Brick Masonry (Brick Industry Association)
Brick Repointing guideline (New York City Housing Authority, 2024)
Peddocks Island: Repointing at Fort Andrews (National Park Service)
Repointing Mortar (Virginia Department of Historic Resources)
Recommended

Comments